Category Archives: Reports

Chmelev saves the day for Kingston 2

Kingston 2 v Guildford 2, Surrey League division 2 match played at the Richard Mayo Centre, United Reformed Church, Kingston on 9 February 2026

Kingston 2 had a somewhat reshaped team for this match. My main concern was that Guildford 2 would turn up with the strength of which they are capable and our new and newish players might then have a discouraging experience.

My worries were half mitigated before and at the start. Guildford’s captain Clive Frostick, himself a Kingston player in the 4NCL, was unable to make the journey. And although we would be heavily outgunned on the top 3 boards, the match-ups looked close on the other four, and given that our new players tend to be improvers, I thought they might sneak a few results. The toss didn’t help – we lost for the sixth time in 7 matches, which in seven- board matches counts for a bit.

On board 2, Alan Scrimgour made a quick draw with Guildford’s stand-in captain Adrian Wallace in a Spanish. The computer evaluation of the final position, a queenless middle game, was indeed level. There was plenty of material and play left for both sides, but Alan was happy to take a draw on one of the “uphill” boards, especially as the situation was starting to look encouraging elsewhere.

Jon Eckert drew first blood with White on board 6 against Alvin Petersen. The game hung on a mistake in the position below.

Next, with White on board 4, Martyn Jones (pictured above in a previous match) terminated Alistair Jennis’s threatening attack by spotting mate the other way.

Guildford hit back in a fluctuating and spectacular battle on board 3 between our Stephen Lovell, who had Black, and Tim Foster.

Around the same time, I succumbed with Black on board 1 to Matthew Dishman, in a game that showed the danger of allowing emotion to override calculation. Early over-optimism was succeeded by premature pessimism.

That meant scores were level with two games still in progress, in both of which the Kingston player was making his second-team debut. So they were both getting a full evening’s entertainment. Could they also get the points to get us over the line in the match?

Constantin Liesch, with Black on board 7 against Anthony Garrood, certainly had a memorable introduction to second-team chess, with a crowd around the board in the later stages of this exciting battle.

That left another second-team debutant, Alex Chmelev, needing to win with Black on board 5 against Guildford veteran Trevor Jones to save the match. Fortunately he had won a pawn around move 20, and by the time spectator attention turned to his board he had reached what looked to be a winning rook and pawn ending, with his king able to get in front of his passed pawn and to the queening square, the textbook condition to win.

It was a long slog – the game went some 80 moves – and there may have been a few detours off the textbook path, but all was well that ended well. So we added a matchpoint to our tally and deprived Guildford of one. Despite being outrated in at least half our matches to date, we stand top of division 2. As the old hands at the club remind us, it is not so long since Kingston 1 were pleased to reach such heights.

Peter Andrews is captain of the Kingston first and second teams in the Surrey League


Kingston beat Coulsdon to reach Alexander Cup final

Coulsdon v Kingston, Alexander Cup semi-final played at Coulsdon Chess Club, Chipstead Valley Road, Coulsdon on 9 February 2026

The build-up to the Alexander Cup semi-final away to Coulsdon was not propitious for Kingston. Two players reported sick, though one managed to suppress his ailments for an evening and play. Young Zain Patel was also sick, but his illness worked to our advantage. He was too ill to fulfil a singing engagement, so was able to replace the player who really was too ill to make it to Coulsdon. The Lord giveth and the Lord taketh away.

A further complication was that we were playing Guildford 2 at home in Surrey division 2 on the same night. We needed strong players for that match as well. Fighting on two fronts is not easy. But the final blow came at 7.33pm, just as the match at Coulsdon was getting under way. The news was relayed via the club WhatsApp group that our 2200-plus board 4 was having a desperate journey south to Coulsdon and would not make it before the half-hour default time. There was only one reserve – a rather feeble player rated 1750. Yes, me. I would do my best, but outrated by 300 points we were almost certainly 1-0 down before we even started.

On board 7, Julian Way and Ian Calvert agreed a quick draw – a reasonable start as Julian had Black against the supersolid Calvert. David Rowson drew on board 8, as did Peter Lalić against the dangerous Ian Snape on board 2. I then went down to my expected defeat – thoroughly deserved as I played a singularly dull game and was out-techniqued by Coulsdon captain Mark Smith. That put Coulsdon 2-5-1.5 up and Kingston’s nerves were jangling.

Peter Hasson calmed those nerves to some degree with a smooth win on board 6 against Amit Kulkarni, whom he had beaten in the corresponding league match at Coulsdon the previous Monday – a useful dress rehearsal. That tied the score at 2.5-2.5 and it quickly became 3-3 when Zain Patel, who had been substantially worse in the opening, secured an important draw against fast-rising junior Rupert Marsden with Black on board 5. If we had lost that game, as had once seemed likely, it really would have been squeaky-bum time. Well played Zain! Did this match really hang on the dodgy state of your vocal cords?

The feeling was that Will Taylor, with Black on board 9, had winning chances against Vedant Papneja. But time was starting to press and Will, in his own words, “blundered into a perpetual on the increment”. That made it 3.5-3.5, and the match was still in the balance.

I could barely bring myself to watch, but Peter Lalić, who was spectating and could actually work out what was going on, was looking confident. He was right to be so – the rest of the match was one-way traffic. Peter Large (pictured above, right), with Black against Evaldas Baltrunas on board 3, converted a complicated endgame; David Maycock got the better of young superstar Supratit Banerjee for the second successive week; and Kingston captain John Foley played a masterful rook and pawn endgame to defeat the doughty Nick Edwards. Kingston had won 6.5-3.5 and we could at last rest easy.

Until the final at least, where a very strong Guildford team awaits us. This eagerly anticipated match is likely to take place in the spring and will have to be played (under Surrey League rules) at a neutral venue, with Ashtead the most likely choice as host as it is roughly equidistant between the two clubs. We thumped Guildford 8-2 in the final last year, but expect it to be closer on this occasion as Guildford have added to their resources and are building a very powerful team.

The incentive for Kingston to retain the trophy is that it would complete a run of five successive Alexander Cup titles – something no team has ever done in the 100-year history of the competition. We feel the weight of history on our shoulders, but will that burden prove too great? Book your tickets for the final now; it is going to be intense … and we hope historic.

Stephen Moss is Kingston club captain

* A fuller account of this match, with game analysis, will be published in early March when the website operatives return from their well-earned mid-season break.

Kingston 1 ease past Coulsdon 1 in crucial encounter

Coulsdon 1 v Kingston 1, Surrey League division 1 match played at Coulsdon Chess Club, Chipstead Valley Road, Coulsdon on 2 February 2026

A trip to Coulsdon is never easy and this was no different. Kingston captain Peter Andrews breathed a sigh of relief when he saw the Coulsdon teamsheet as they were missing a few strong players, but they still gave us plenty to think about on the night, and we were relieved to run out 6.5-1.5 winners.

Peter Hasson’s game – he had White on board 5 – was first to finish. Indeed it was over in less than an hour and a half, way ahead of any of the other seven games. Peter played a beautifully thematic game in a Symmetrical English and won in 27 moves. This was the denouement, though the game was really won thanks to a series of small positional pluses earlier in the game.

Inevitably when FMs David Maycock and Supratit Banerjee clash, their game always generates a good deal of interest. Supratit plays for Kingston in 4NCL and the Thames Valley League, but tonight he was on the opposing team. David had the advantage of White – it was a good toss for Peter Andrews to win – but he had the worst of the opening exchanges, and, as they entered the middle game, Supratit was pressing. Black has an advantage in the position below because of the pin on the knight on c4 and White’s doubled e-pawns. I was convinced Supratit would win, but David is a master complicator, time started to take its toll, and the game began to turn around.

Jasper Tambini, with White, and veteran Nick Edwards had a hard-fought draw on board 7. Jasper gave up a pawn for the initiative in the opening, but Nick found an imaginative way of returning it to neutralise White’s attack, forcing a draw. On board 4, John Hawksworth felt he was better out of the opening but, in his words, “spent too much time looking for something immediately decisive (which didn’t exist according to the engine).” He then blundered a pawn, but still felt he was better with the two bishops, forgoing a nailed-on draw in pursuit of a victory which eventually turned into a defeat in a time scramble.

David Rowson, bottom left, playing alongside Peter Hasson and John Hawksworth on the middle boards

There was better news on board 6, where David Rowson steadily outplayed his opponent with a pair of knights against a pair of bishops to secure a win. When the position below was reached, David has given up both his bishops for knights, judging correctly that White’s fractured pawn structure and the bishops’ restricted movement will favour him. Now he decides to press.

David summed up the game with characteristic modesty: “Nothing dramatic, and my opponent didn’t play very strongly, but I was pleased that I made some of the right choices (such as swapping bishop for knight and playing g5 – not a move I usually play lightly) and that I was able to show that my knights were better than his bishops.” Captain Andrews appreciated it too: “A nice example of a caged bishop, with nowhere to go from g3, and a game where there wasn’t a single moment of decision, rather incremental outplaying.”

Peter himself also won with Black on board 8. White has a small plus in the position below, but Black has an immediate threat which must be countered. Unfortunately for Peter’s opponent, he fails to see it and the small plus becomes a hefty minus.

On board 3, Peter Large had White against Ian Calvert, who is something of a draw specialist. A lengthy technical battle ensued in which Peter gradually established the upper hand.

Another intense technical battle was raging on board 2, where Peter Lalić was playing Coulsdon captain Mark Smith. Peter went for one of his speciality queenless middle games and thereafter shuffled with purpose, though White did have a fleeting chance in the position below.

That made it four wins for Peters and two for Davids in a very satisfying 6.5-1.5 victory which takes Kingston back to the top of Surrey League division 1. We now face another tough trip to Coulsdon this coming Monday (9 February) for the semi-final of the 10-board Alexander Cup. We will be hoping for a similar result as we target a historic five-timer in this hallowed competition. No other club has managed more than four successive wins in the Alexander Cup. To win five in a row really would be something to shout about.

Stephen Moss is Kingston club captain

Wallington default boosts Kingston 3 promotion hopes

Kingston 3 v Wallington, Surrey League division 4 match due to be played at the Richard Mayo Centre, United Reformed Church, Kingston on 2 February 2026

Disappointingly, Wallington were unable to fulfil this Surrey division 4 fixture, so Kingston 3 claimed the match by default. Under the rules of the Surrey League, this means that Wallington lose on all boards, giving Kingston a 6-0 victory – a fillip in the team’s bid to win promotion. Kingston 3 are currently top of the division, but only narrowly on game points from Epsom 4. The battle is likely to go to the wire, with ambitious Epsom pressing hard.

Wallington had been unable to raise a team to come to Kingston for this match earlier in the season and Kingston 3 captain Edward Mospan had generously allowed a rearrangement of the fixture. But on this occasion it was felt that we should claim a win by default. We thank Wallington for giving us ample warning of the cancellation, which allowed the Kingston players due to take part in the match to be paired in the regular rated friendlies (pictured above) which are now a feature of club nights at the United Reformed Church in central Kingston, the club’s new home.

Stephen Moss, Kingston club captain

Outrated Kingston 2 spring surprise at Epsom

Epsom 2 v Kingston 2, Surrey League division 2 match played at the Epsom Christian Fellowship on 26 January 2026

It had been only a fortnight since our tightly fought home draw v Epsom 2, and less than two months since Kingston 1 were defeated by Epsom 1, with three of our side for this latest match and four of theirs also present on that occasion. But to plagiarise the comedian Eric Morecambe for elite chess, we may have been playing the same people, but not necessarily in the same order.

Epsom captain Marcus Gosling (pictured above, directing operations at the start of the match) used the full tolerance allowed by Surrey League rules to promote players in form, notably the fast-rising junior Lev Razhnou, who had added 100 points to his rating between early November and mid December. I had been one of his victims in that run, and had seen him grind down the Essex board 2 in a county U2050 match at the weekend in an endgame, usually a hallmark of class. So we reassured David Rowson, who was to face him, that if he got a result it would be one to treasure when Lev achieves stardom in a few years.

Martyn Jones on board 6 also drew a tough assignment, facing former British champion Peter Lee, while Stephen Moss, who had stepped in at a late stage for the unwell John Foley, was also outrated by his young opponent on board 7. We were clearly outrated on four boards, about evenly matched on two, and only had a significant advantage on board 3.

A challenging task was mitigated by winning the toss for the first time this season (in our 6th match), which gave us four Whites out of seven boards, and probably gave us the colours we wanted for the match-ups – three of our four outrated players had White, and in the middle order Rowson and I are just as likely to score with Black, while Jasper Tambini’s style may better suit White.       

Julian Way played a sensible if unexciting game against James Allison on top board giving us an early draw on one of our “uphill” boards. But Martyn Jones succumbed on board 6, though as he put it there were “plenty of learnings” against such an experienced opponent. I was unable to see much of the rest of the match because of the excitement in my own game on board 4 versus Gosling. Those of my team-mates who saw the game will probably have counted it as a win from early on, but given my previous game with Marcus it didn’t feel that way.

I emerged from my trance over this game to find that on board 3 Jasper Tambini had squashed Chris Wright in a game which carried a useful lesson about engine analysis.

On board 2, David Rowson’s game with Black against Lev Razhnou did not quite live up to its billing. There were some tactical slips on both sides, starting with David losing a pawn but taking the initiative in the middle game, and culminating in an ending in which his pawn advantage with a goodish bishop v knight and connected passed pawns on the kingside were winning, one might have thought easily. But even in endgames chess can be a difficult and cruel game. With both players in acute time trouble, White had one chance to turn the tables.

Thankfully I didn’t see that, or my nerves might not have been fit to drive home. As it was, I came round from my own game to find that we were now 3.5-1.5 ahead, with boards 5 and 7 still going. A draw from one of them would be sufficient to win the match.

On board 7, Stephen Moss had a fighting game with another rising Epsom junior, Maya Keen, in which he dodged several bullets.

Just as Stephen was congratulated by his team-mates for getting us over the line, Homayoon Froogh also delivered a draw. This was a fine result against Robin Haldane, a scourge of Kingston this season having already beaten Peter Hasson in the first-team match in December and Jasper Tambini in the second- team match in early January. Homayoon was never worse, and at the time it felt like a solid and accurate performance. So it was frustrating for him to show his effort to Mr Stockfish next day and find that he had missed an immediate win.

So we had won 4.5-2.5 despite being outrated, a great team effort celebrated with the doughnuts generously brought by Peter Lalic, who came to watch the end of the match. Almost all the games were hard and long, and several of them contained missed one-move opportunities to change the course of history. Which goes to show that chess is hard for humans, but that, along with humour between the teams and doughnuts, is what makes the game worth playing.  

Peter Andrews is Kingston captain in Surrey division 2

CSC/Kingston 1 fall to might of Wood Green

The second round of 4NCL matches, spread across two weekends in January, saw mixed results for CSC/Kingston’s three teams, with a setback in division 1 but solid progress in division 3

For a moment we dared to dream. After two victories on the opening weekend, including a remarkable 6-2 victory over GM-laden Cheddleton, we had started to believe our own publicity. Might we actually be able to win the competition? Unfortunately, the answer was a resounding no: on the Saturday of Weekend 2 (10 January) we drew with Barnet Knights and the following day we lost 5.5-2.5 to Wood Green, by some margin the strongest team at 4NCL. Oh well, it was fun while it lasted.

We had taken a very strong team to Coventry in the hope that we could spring a surprise: Polish grandmaster Jakub Kosakowski on board 1, former British champion Harry Grieve on 3, GM Ameet Ghasi on 3, youthful Ukrainian IM Vlad Larkin on 4 – but our opponents had strengthened too.

The match on Saturday against Barnet Knights ended in a thrilling 4-4 draw, with Grieve pressing hard for a win against GM Eldar Gasanov on his debut for CSC/Kingston. On Sunday, we were outgunned on the lower boards – every Wood Green player was 2400-plus – though the result could have been closer. Ulysse Bottazzi was on top against IM Jonah Willow until time trouble undermined him. A good learning experience for all of us – this league is tough! The players remained in good spirits and, as the photograph above shows, happily played blitz and bughouse late into the night on Saturday. Good for team bonding, if not for early-morning prep on Sunday.

CSC/Kingston 2, playing on the same weekend and at the same venue – a Holiday Inn somewhere on the M6 – had a more successful weekend in their quest to win promotion from division 3 (knights). They beat south-west London neighbours Surbiton 4.5-1.5 on Saturday, and followed it up with victory by the same margin over Ashfield on Sunday. Peter Finn and Clive Frostick both scored 2/2, and everyone contributed in what has become a tightly knit and very effective unit. The team is now 4/4 after two weekends and sit proudly atop the division (see tables at foot of report).

CSC/Kingston 3 played in division 4 a week later (17/18 January) in Dudley and suffered a 5.5-0.5 hammering by the evocatively (sic) named FCPL-UK on Saturday. FCPL-UK were outrated, so one can only assume they have some seriously underrated players. Or perhaps we just had a bad day at the office. Anyway, well done to Chris Rice for securing the half-point which avoided the dreaded “bagelling” (ie 6-0, as in a very one-sided set in tennis).

Sunday was a much better day, and CSC/Kingston 3 bounced back with a convincing 4.5-1.5 victory over Crowthorne B to leave the team eighth of 30 teams in the table (division 4 is a Swiss, unlike the other divisions which are all-play-alls). Chris Rice and Giampiero Amato won, as did Kingston junior (and British under-10 champion) William Lin on his debut weekend at 4NCL.

A great result for William and, despite the Wood Green setback, a generally encouraging set of results for the 44-strong CSC/Kingston squad. Thanks as ever to squad matriarch Kate Cooke for looking after the players, booking the hotels and making the logistics work. Weekend 3, when all three teams play on the same days (7/8 February) in Coventry and Daventry, promises to be even more complicated.

The tables after Weekend 2

Stephen Moss is Kingston club captain

Kingston 4 secure fighting draw against Dorking 2

Kingston 4 v Dorking 2, Surrey League division 5 match played at the Richard Mayo Centre, United Reformed Church, Kingston on 26 January 2026

This drawn match was a good result for our fourth team against Dorking 2 and a sign that we are developing more strength in depth as a club. We are also growing! New members Tom Mayers and Sebastian Allam made their first appearances for Kingston in this match.

Dorking had strong players on the top two boards, so for Kingston to win them both was exceptional. Dorking were too strong for us in the middle order, and won on boards 3, 4 and 5. As I know from bitter experience, Peter Horlock is seriously underrated at 1569. But Nette Robinson, who is in a rich vein of form, won with Black on board six to tie the match at 3-3. An excellent outcome for for Ed Mospan’s team given the rating disparity.

Stephen Moss, captain of Kingston Chess Club

Ruthless Kingston 3 wallop Wallington

Wallington v Kingston 3, Surrey League division 4 match played at Wallington United Reformed Church on 21 January 2026

The visit to Wallington ended in an emphatic 5-1 win for Ed Mospan’s team. The success included wins on boards 1 and 3 by players new to Kingston this season, plus excellent performances by some seasoned club players.

Alexander Chmelev, one of the new arrivals, won well on board 1 against a highly rated rival, and another newcomer, the talented Thivan Gunawardana, won a thrilling game with White on board 3. With both players in severe time trouble, Black resigned in the position below when he was actually winning!. Zeitnot can do the strangest things.

Jon Eckert constructed a neat mating net with Black on board 2; Seth Warren won smoothly on board 4; and Genc Tasbasi overwhelmed his opponent on board 5. Wallington gained a consolation win on board 6, where Ed Mospan’s young opponent played well to win with a well-oiled London System. Ed, though, is a team man, and his side’s victory will mean more to him than his own reverse.

Stephen Moss, captain of Kingston Chess Club

Maidenhead A get the better of Kingston B

Maidenhead A v Kingston B, Thames Valley division 1 match played at St Luke’s Community Hall, Maidenhead on 19 January 2026

Another Monday evening, another trip to Maidenhead. Last week it had been our A team making the journey, and now it was our B team, but for two of us, Peter Hasson and me, it was a return trip, as we played in both matches.

The Maidenhead team was very similar to the previous week apart from the absence of GM Matthew Wadsworth and the addition of John Wager. The average ratings of the two teams on the night were almost identical, and this was reflected in the play, but unfortunately for Kingston (spoiler alert) Maidenhead succeeded in winning games in which they were at best slightly better early on and drawing games in which they were slightly worse.

Having said that, on board 4 the result might have gone Maidenhead’s way if John Wager had found the winning line in the ending. In the middlegame the centre and kingside had become blocked, which meant that the question was whether White could exploit his advanced pawn chain on the queenside. He managed to get a pawn to a7, but John Foley blocked this with a knight, resulting in this position:

Shortly after this, Alan Scrimgour and Tony Milnes also agreed a draw. The game had started as a French Defence Winawer Variation, with complex play on both sides of the board. In the end the players were happy to share the point.

Prior to my own game I had noticed that Andrew Smith usually played the Centre Game, but, as he told me afterwards, he has very recently started to try out the Ruy Lopez. However, he admitted that he was unfamiliar with the line I played, and after 19 moves I had reached a comfortable position:

The board 3 game began with a classical Closed Ruy Lopez. Jasper Tambini, with White, established a knight on d6, but Stephen James had counterplay through his bishop on the a8-h1 diagonal and his rook on g6:

So the score was Maidenhead 2.5 Kingston 1.5 with two games to finish. The board 6 game between Maidenhead’s Charles Bullock, with White, and Kingston’s Homayoon Froogh opened with the Slav Defence. In the position below White is looking threatening on the kingside, but, as Homayoon noted afterwards, if he had played 25…Nc5 or Qc6 he would have been at least equal, as White’s next move would not have been possible.

Maidenhead now had a decisive two-game lead. In the remaining game, on top board, Peter Hasson (pictured above left), with White, had achieved an advantage, since Bohdan Terler’s h-pawn advance backfired, as can be seen in the diagram below (after Black’s 29th move):

Thus the match ended in a Maidenhead win by 4-2. We could dwell on the might-have-beens, but better to move on and do our best to obtain the points we need to stay in the division.

David Rowson, captain of Kingston B in Thames Valley division 1

Nerveless Lovell saves the day for Kingston 2

Kingston 2 v Epsom 2, Surrey League division 2 match played at the Richard Mayo Centre, United Reformed Church, Kingston on 12 January 2026

A match against Epsom always has a special flavour. The unstoppable force meets the immoveable object. We see ourselves as a pukkah Sherlock Holmes, while the likeable (but very determined and adroit) Epsom president-for-life Marcus Gosling is (in the nicest way possible) the Professor Moriarty of Surrey chess. It is a battle for domination. The Reichenbach Falls probably beckon, which is another way of saying that, amid the egomania of Epsom and Kingston, the quiet professionalism of Coulsdon and Guildford will probably eventually prevail. Anyway, leaving aside this powerful subtext, this was an excellent match which ended in a 3.5-3.5 draw.

Martyn Jones got Kingston off to a winning start with victory on board 7 over promising junior Ethan Bogerd (a Kingston member currently playing for Professor Moriarty’s team). But another of the professor’s large crop of promising juniors, Sachin Kumar, equalised with a win on board 3 in an opposite-coloured bishop endgame which Kingston president John Foley thought he could hold despite being a pawn down. Sachin played superbly on the increment to prove John wrong.

On top board, Julian Way and James Allison had a high-class tussle which ended in a draw. Allison, who played for Ashtead last season, is proving a terrific recruit for the professor and rising significantly in the ratings. On board 6, Epsom’s Chris Wright was always material up against Xavier Cowan and duly converted, while on board 2 that wily old fox Robin Haldane had too many tactical tricks for Jasper Tambini. Robin, the nicest of men but the doughtiest of opponents, is turning into something of a nemesis for Kingston this season. It was looking like Epsom would take the spoils, but there was a twist in the tale.

Alan Scrimgour played a lovely game to beat former British champion Peter Lee with White on board 4. He has analysed the game in the blogs section alongside his win in 2004 against another British champion, Bob Wade, pointing out that both victories hinged on the same piece sacrifice.

That made the score 3.5-2.5 to Epsom, and the fate of the match was in the hands of the professor himself, with White on board 5 against the gentle but resilient Stephen Lovell (pictured above, left foreground). The protagonists were both playing on the increment; spectators clustered round the board; match scores were thrust under the players’ noses so they understood the significance of the game result – a draw was enough for Epsom; Stephen didn’t seem to twig that he had to win, which was perhaps just as well as he might have frozen. The Reichenbach Falls swirled below. Stephen has annotated the match-defining game below.

With one bound we were free and the match drawn. The professor looked disconsolate. The journey back to Epsom would be a painful one. Honours were even in a division that is proving very competitive and unpredictable. Kingston and Epsom had nullified each other in their unending struggle. The story will be continued …

Stephen Moss, captain of Kingston Chess Club